“These guys do CRO the right way.” - Shaan Puri, Host, My First Million Podcast

SubscriptionsComparison / Guide

What's the Best Shopify Subscription App for Your Store? (2026)

The best Shopify subscription apps compared: Recharge, Loop, Skio, Stay AI, Appstle, Seal and Shopify's free app, starting from $0 to $599 a month.

Federico Reyes Arce
Federico Reyes ArceSenior CRO and Growth Strategist, DTC Pages
16 min read
Best Shopify subscription apps compared: starting price and Shopify App Store rating for Shopify Subscriptions, Seal, Appstle, Loop, Recharge, Stay AI and Skio, as of November 2026.

The best Shopify subscription app depends on your size and how much you want to pay as you grow. Shopify Subscriptions is free and fits a store testing simple subscribe and save. Seal and Appstle start free and charge flat monthly fees with no transaction fee on paid plans, so they fit stores that want low, predictable costs. Loop fits growing brands that want retention tools without a high fixed fee. Recharge, Stay AI and Skio charge a monthly fee plus a fee on each order, and fit brands that want a full platform with migration help.

DTC Pages is a Loop and Intelligems agency partner. No company paid to be included or reviewed in this guide.

How do the best Shopify subscription apps compare?#

They split into two pricing camps: a flat fee, or a flat fee plus a cut of every subscription order. Prices, ratings and review counts are as of November 2026, from each vendor's pricing page and its Shopify App Store listing.

AppBest forStarting priceShopify App Store rating (reviews)
RechargeEstablished brands wanting built-in testing$149/month + 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction4.8 (3,162)
LoopGrowing brands wanting low fixed feesFree up to 50 subscriptions; $99/month + 1% on Starter4.9 (820)
SkioHigh-volume brands wanting one core plan$599/month ($499 billed annually) + 1.25% + 20¢ per subscription order5.0 (249)
Stay AIBuilt-in testing of offers and flows$299/month on its listing, $499 on its pricing page, + 1% + 19¢ per transaction4.9 (148)
Shopify SubscriptionsStores starting simple subscribe and saveFree3.8 (916)
AppstleFull feature set on a budgetFree up to $500/month in subscription revenue; paid from $10/month5.0 (9,317)
SealSmall stores with modest subscriber countsFree up to 50 subscriptions; paid from $5.95/month4.9 (3,183)

DTC Pages has dashboard access to subscription programs on Recharge, Loop, Skio and Stay AI, the same programs behind our retention benchmarks. We haven't used Appstle or Seal hands-on, so those sections are based on their documentation.

Who is Recharge best for?#

Recharge is best for established brands that want built-in A/B testing, bundles and migration support on one platform, and are comfortable with a fee on every transaction.

  • Pricing. As of November 2026, the Recharge pricing page lists Starter at $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction, with a 60-day free trial, and Scale at $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢. A Custom plan has volume-based rates, and the page says Shopify Plus merchants may get discounted pricing through it. Usage fees apply to all transactions Recharge processes.
  • Rating. 4.8 stars from 3,162 reviews on its Shopify App Store listing.
  • Features. Every plan includes a product page widget, a customer portal with passwordless login where customers swap products and reschedule deliveries, Smart Cancellation Prevention with targeted offers and A/B testing, failed payment recovery, win-backs, and analytics with industry benchmarks. Scale adds customizable bundles, subscriber journey A/B testing and end-to-end migration support. Recharge's docs describe a self-service migration tool and a way to A/B test the subscription widget.
  • Shopify requirements. New checkouts run through the Shopify checkout, and recurring orders go through Shopify Payments or another eligible gateway.
  • Limits. Bundles, Concierge SMS and the developer SDK start on Scale, and the per-transaction fee grows with your subscription revenue.

Who is Loop best for?#

Loop is best for growing brands that want cancellation flows, bundles and loyalty on a lower fixed fee than Recharge, Stay AI or Skio.

  • Pricing. As of November 2026, Loop's Shopify App Store listing shows a Free Forever plan up to 50 active subscriptions. The Loop pricing page lists Starter at $99 a month plus a 1% transaction fee and Pro at $399 a month plus 0.75%, with no fixed fee per subscription order, only the percentage. Loyalty orders add 15¢ on Starter and 10¢ on Pro. Paid plans are month to month with a 14-day free trial, and Enterprise pricing is negotiable.
  • Rating. 4.9 stars from 820 reviews on its Shopify App Store listing.
  • Features. Paid plans include a branded customer portal with upsells, personalized cancellation flows, smart dunning, build-your-own and preset bundles, native loyalty and referrals, storefront widgets, and subscriber and cancellation analytics. Pro adds cancellation flow A/B testing, win-back campaigns, prepaid subscriptions and multilingual support. Loop's migration FAQ lists a self-migration tool for Recharge, Smartrr, Bold, Skio and Seal, typically in 3 to 7 working days, and the pricing page says migration is free.
  • Shopify requirements. Loop's general FAQ says it doesn't restrict features by Shopify plan. The one exception on its pricing page is checkout upgrades, which need Shopify Plus.
  • Limits. Prepaid and trial subscriptions, a multilingual portal and Shopify Markets support are Pro only, and the free plan stops at 50 subscriptions.

Who is Skio best for?#

Skio is best for high-volume brands that want one core plan and can carry a $499 to $599 monthly fee.

  • Pricing. As of November 2026, the Skio pricing page lists Scale at $599 a month billed monthly or $499 billed annually, plus 1.25% + 20¢ on orders involving a subscription. Enterprise is custom, with volume pricing, and loyalty is an extra charge.
  • Rating. 5.0 stars from 249 reviews on its Shopify App Store listing, which now names the app "Skio, a Recharge Company".
  • Features. The plan includes a multi-step cancel flow builder, build-a-box, analytics with segmentation, SMS, lifecycle journeys and payment recovery. The customer portal uses passwordless login, and customers can skip, pause, swap items, change frequency, cancel and reactivate. Skio's migration overview says Shopify Payments needs no action, while Stripe and PayPal need connecting.
  • Shopify requirements. One login option, Multipass, requires Shopify Plus.
  • Limits. Its starting fee is the highest in this guide. Skio is now part of Recharge, and Skio's announcement says both platforms keep running while they are combined over time, so ask about the roadmap before you sign.

Who is Stay AI best for?#

Stay AI is best for brands that want built-in A/B testing across offers and flows, with every feature on one plan.

  • Pricing. As of November 2026, its Shopify App Store listing shows $299 a month plus 1% + 19¢ per transaction, with a 30-day free trial. The Stay AI pricing page shows a Standard plan at $499 a month with the same transaction fee and "all features included", plus a custom High Growth plan. Neither page names a contract term, so confirm which price and term apply to you before you sign.
  • Rating. 4.9 stars from 148 reviews on the listing.
  • Features. The pricing page lists churn surveys, win-back campaigns, A/B testing, bundles and boxes, prepaid subscriptions and workflows. The customer portal uses a one-time code, so customers don't need an account. Stay AI says there is no implementation charge when you migrate, and that migrations take up to two weeks.
  • Limits. It has the fewest App Store reviews of the paid platforms, and its two published prices don't match.

Who is Shopify Subscriptions best for?#

Shopify Subscriptions is best for stores adding a simple subscribe and save option for the first time, because the app itself costs nothing.

  • Pricing. Free on its Shopify App Store listing as of November 2026. Gateway fees still apply, including third-party transaction fees on PayPal Express if Shopify Payments isn't active.
  • Rating. 3.8 stars from 916 reviews, the lowest rating in this guide.
  • Features. Weekly, monthly or yearly plans with subscribe and save, fixed or custom pricing. In customer accounts, customers can skip, pause, resume and cancel, and update their payment method and address. Its analytics show four metrics: subscription revenue, active, new and canceled. You can import contracts from a third-party app by CSV.
  • Shopify requirements. Shopify's considerations page lists the gateways it works with: Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen for approved organizations, and Stripe for select merchants. Your theme must support sections and blocks. Shopify Plus isn't required.
  • Limits. The same page says bundles aren't compatible, gift cards apply only to the first payment, and discounts from function-based apps apply only to the first payment by default. Cancellation happens after one confirmation step, and Shopify doesn't document retention offers.

Who is Appstle best for?#

Appstle is best for budget-conscious stores that want build-a-box, prepaid plans and retention offers without a transaction fee. This section is based on Appstle's documentation, not hands-on use.

  • Pricing. As of November 2026, its Shopify App Store listing shows a free plan up to $500 a month in subscription revenue, Starter at $10 a month up to $5,000, Business at $30 up to $15,000 and Business Premium at $100 up to $100,000. Paid plans charge a 0% transaction fee, with a 14-day free trial. Enterprise pricing is on request.
  • Rating. 5.0 stars from 9,317 reviews, the most in this guide.
  • Features. A customer portal with one-click login, pay-as-you-go and prepaid plans, build-a-box and bundles, and performance analytics. Its retention offers can match the cancel reason with a discount, skip, pause, product swap or free gift, from the Business plan up. Appstle says migration is free on all plans, from apps including Recharge, Loop, Seal and Bold.
  • Shopify requirements. Its FAQ lists Shopify Payments, Authorize.net and PayPal as supported gateways. Shopify Plus isn't required.
  • Limits. Each plan caps your monthly subscription revenue, and moving below Business turns retention offers off.

Who is Seal best for?#

Seal is best for small stores with a modest number of subscribers that want the lowest flat fee and no transaction fees. This section is based on Seal's documentation, not hands-on use.

  • Pricing. As of November 2026, the Seal pricing page prices plans by the total number of subscriptions in the app, not just active ones: free up to 50, $5.95 a month up to 100, $9.95 up to 250, $24.95 up to 500 and $89.95 up to 2,000, with larger plans up to 150,000 subscriptions at $399. No plan charges a transaction fee.
  • Rating. 4.9 stars from 3,183 reviews on its Shopify App Store listing.
  • Features. A passwordless customer portal where customers pause, skip and edit their subscription, product swaps, subscription boxes and real-time analytics. A custom cancellation flow starts on the $9.95 Rising Star plan. Seal's migration FAQ describes an import wizard for Recharge and Bold, plus CSV import.
  • Shopify requirements. The FAQ says automatic charging needs a supported gateway such as Shopify Payments, Stripe, Authorize.net or PayPal Express.
  • Limits. Every plan caps the total number of subscriptions, and the FAQ says Seal doesn't have native bundles, which need a separate app.

How do you choose a subscription app?#

Choose on five things: what it costs at your volume, how it handles cancellations, how it fits your checkout and theme, whether you can test your offer with it, and how you would move in.

Cost as you scale. Flat-fee apps charge by tier, so the bill steps up as you grow. Apps with a transaction fee add a percentage of every subscription order on top of their monthly fee. Take a store billing $100,000 a month in subscription revenue across 2,000 orders, with every subscription billed once a month, so 2,000 active subscriptions. At the listed prices, the monthly bill looks like this:

App and planMonthly cost in this example
Recharge Starter$2,049
Skio, billed monthly$2,249
Stay AI, at its listing price$1,679
Loop Starter, before loyalty orders$1,099
Appstle Business Premium$100
Seal, 2,000-subscription plan$89.95

Seal counts the total number of subscriptions in the app, not just active ones, so check that number before you pick its tier. Payment processing, your Shopify plan and add-ons come on top of all of them.

Retention tools. In our subscription retention benchmarks, 45% to 56% of a signup cohort was still subscribed at month three, and 89% of churn was voluntary on average across four programs: people who went into their account and cancelled. A cancellation flow that offers a skip, a pause or a swap works on that 89%. Payment recovery works on the rest.

Shopify checkout and your theme. Recharge, Loop, Skio, Stay AI, Appstle, Seal and Shopify Subscriptions all list Shopify's checkout as supported. Check the gateway list before you pick: automatic renewals only run on the gateways each app supports, and Shopify Subscriptions also needs a theme with sections and blocks.

A/B testing your offer. Recharge, Stay AI and Loop (on Pro) have native A/B testing for parts of the subscription experience. Recharge includes A/B testing in its cancellation flows on every plan, keeps subscriber journey A/B testing for Scale, and documents a widget test. For price and discount tests, Intelligems' subscription docs name Recharge, Stay AI, Skio and Loop among supported apps, through duplicate products. Skio and Loop list Intelligems in their own docs. Shopify Subscriptions, Appstle and Seal aren't named on that Intelligems page.

Migration. Most of these apps migrate you for free or with a built-in tool. If you also change payment processor, read Shopify's payment method migration guide first: depending on where your customers' cards are stored, they stay in place, move through a token migration with your app developer, or need some subscribers to re-enter their card.

Why won't the app fix your subscription offer?#

Because the app only processes what your product page sells. How many people subscribe depends on choices you control on that page, whichever app runs behind it.

Three of them matter most:

  • Default selection. Whether subscribe or one-time purchase is selected when the page loads.
  • How savings are shown. A percentage, a price per delivery, or the money saved over a year.
  • Frequency options. How many intervals you offer and which one is preselected.

Each one is a test, not a setting. Testing the subscription offer on the store took Happy Mammoth to +134% subscription orders, and ROYO to +167% subscription revenue and +173% subscription orders. Those results came from testing the offer, so they aren't attributable to any subscription app. Across 1,379 A/B tests we ran on more than 40 Shopify stores between 2021 and 2026, 37.9% produced a winner, so test before you roll a change out. Our A/B testing service covers how we run these.

How did we choose these apps?#

We covered four platforms that charge on subscription revenue (Recharge, Loop, Skio and Stay AI), Shopify's own free app, and two flat-fee apps with thousands of App Store reviews (Appstle and Seal), and compared each on pricing model, retention tools, Shopify requirements, migration help and how you can test your offer with it. We have dashboard access to subscription programs on Recharge, Loop, Skio and Stay AI, and cover Appstle and Seal from their documentation. Every price, rating, review count and feature comes from the vendor's site, its documentation or its Shopify App Store listing, checked in November 2026. Where a vendor's own pages disagree we say so, and anything we couldn't confirm from an official source is left out.

Related Posts

Frequently Asked Questions#

Is Shopify Subscriptions enough?#

For simple subscribe and save, yes. It's free, lets customers skip, pause and cancel in their account, and imports contracts from other apps by CSV. As of November 2026, Shopify's docs say it doesn't support bundles, and they don't describe retention offers when a customer cancels. If you need build-a-box, cancellation offers or deeper analytics, a third-party app covers more.

How much do subscription apps cost?#

As of November 2026, starting prices run from $0 to $599 a month before transaction fees. Shopify Subscriptions is free. Seal and Appstle start free and charge flat fees with no transaction fee on paid plans. Loop starts free on its App Store listing, then $99 a month plus 1%. Recharge starts at $149 plus 1.50% + 20¢, Stay AI at $299 or $499 plus 1% + 19¢, and Skio at $599 plus 1.25% + 20¢.

Can I switch from Recharge to another app?#

Yes. Loop's self-migration tool supports Recharge, Appstle migrates from Recharge for free, Seal has an import wizard that uses your Recharge API key, and Shopify Subscriptions imports contracts by CSV. If you also change payment processor, cards may stay in place, move through a token migration with your app developer, or need some subscribers to re-enter them, depending on where they're stored.

Do subscription apps work with Shopify's checkout?#

Yes. Recharge, Loop, Skio, Stay AI, Appstle, Seal and Shopify Subscriptions list Shopify's checkout as supported. Renewals still need a payment gateway Shopify supports for subscriptions, such as Shopify Payments, PayPal Express or Authorize.net. Shopify notes that local and manual payment methods may not work for subscriptions.

Which subscription app is best for Shopify Plus?#

Shopify Subscriptions, Loop and Appstle say Plus isn't required, and the Plus-specific items we found are small: Recharge offers Plus merchants discounted Custom pricing, Loop's checkout upgrades need Plus, and Skio's Multipass login needs Plus. At Plus volume, compare Recharge Custom, Skio Enterprise, Stay AI High Growth and Loop Enterprise on the per-order fees they quote you.

Can I A/B test my subscription offer?#

Yes. Recharge, Stay AI and Loop have native A/B testing on some plans, and Recharge documents how to test its subscription widget. Intelligems supports price tests with Recharge, Stay AI, Skio and Loop through duplicate products. Test the default selection, how savings are shown and the frequency options first.

Do I need a paid subscription app to retain subscribers?#

Not to start, but a cancellation flow helps. In our retention benchmarks, 89% of churn was voluntary on average across four programs, so offering a skip, pause or swap when someone cancels works on most of the people you lose. Shopify Subscriptions doesn't document retention offers, while Appstle includes them from its $30 Business plan and Loop on its paid plans.

Next Steps#

Picking the app is the smaller decision. What decides how many people subscribe is the offer on your product page, and that's something you can test. See how we run those tests on our A/B testing service page, or book a strategy call and we'll look at your subscription offer together. If you want a team to run the whole program, see what we do as a Shopify CRO agency.

Want us to run this for your store?

We help Shopify brands increase revenue through data-driven CRO. Book a free strategy call.

Book a Free Call

Ready to grow your Shopify store?

We help Shopify brands increase revenue through A/B testing, landing pages, and conversion rate optimization. No contracts, just results.