“These guys do CRO the right way.” - Shaan Puri, Host, My First Million Podcast

Benchmarks & DataBenchmarks / Data

Is Your Free Shipping Threshold Too High or Too Low? How to Tell

Is your free shipping threshold too high or too low? What 27 A/B tests on Shopify stores show, and why profit per visitor decides it.

Federico Reyes Arce
Federico Reyes ArceSenior CRO and Growth Strategist, DTC Pages
Updated November 2, 202612 min read
Same cart, two free shipping thresholds: at $225 a $199.99 shoe is $25.01 short and conversion fell 10.3%; at $199 the same shoe ships free and conversion rose 7.5%

Your free shipping threshold is too high or too low depending on one number: profit per visitor. There is no right threshold for every store, and the only reliable way to find yours is to test it. Across 27 free shipping tests DTC Pages ran for 14 Shopify brands between 2021 and 2026, the clearest wins came when the new threshold matched a basket shoppers were already buying, and the clearest losses came when conversion went up but profit went down.

Many brands ask us what their free shipping threshold should be based on their AOV, or whether they should raise it, lower it or leave it alone. Most of the time our answer is "let's test it." We can't know in advance which threshold will work best for a specific store. What we can share is what to look at before you test, how to judge the result, and what we learned from each test we ran.

Can you set the right threshold without testing it?#

Not reliably. The usual advice is to set the threshold a bit above your average order value so it pulls carts up. Our tests show why that rule falls short.

A premium footwear brand had a threshold so high that only about 1 in 10 orders qualified for free shipping. On paper, that's a threshold that is too high. So we lowered it by 10%, and conversion fell 10.29%. Two weeks later we tested a deeper cut, to a little below the store's AOV, and conversion rose 7.5%.

Same store, same shoppers, same direction of change. One lost and one won. The difference was what a shopper had to put in the cart. The brand's most common price tier sat just above the deeper cut, so a single pair qualified on its own. With the smaller cut, that same shopper still had to add an accessory to get free shipping.

Same footwear store, two threshold cuts: cutting by 10% lowered conversion about 10%, cutting to just below average order value raised conversion about 7%.

A household products brand had the same problem. Its core product plus its most common add-on came to just under the threshold, so the most natural basket never qualified. Lowering the threshold just enough for that basket to qualify won.

The threshold isn't really measured against your AOV. It's measured against what people already buy. You can estimate that from your own orders, but only a test tells you whether it pays.

Why is profit per visitor the metric that decides it?#

Because free shipping is a cost, and conversion rate doesn't see it.

When you lower the threshold, more orders ship free and you pay for those shipments. When you raise it, you collect shipping on more orders but some shoppers leave. A threshold test moves conversion, AOV and shipping cost at the same time, often in different directions. Profit per visitor is the one number that adds them up: what you keep from each visitor after product cost, discounts and the shipping you pay.

TestConversion rateAOVProfit per visitorResult
Home decor brand, threshold cut to well below AOV+3.00%-9.89%-8.42%Original kept
Footwear brand, threshold cut by 10%-10.29%+4.85%-5.66%Original kept
Footwear brand, threshold cut to a little below AOV+7.5%-3.6%+2.9%Won on conversion, profit trending up
Conversion and profit per visitor in three free shipping threshold tests: a home decor cut raised conversion 3.0% but cut profit per visitor 8.4%; a 10% footwear cut lowered conversion 10.3% and profit per visitor 5.7%; a footwear cut to a little below AOV raised conversion 7.5% and profit per visitor 2.9%.

The home decor test is the clearest example. Its threshold sat above its AOV, so lowering it looked like an easy win. With the deepest cut, conversion went up 3%. But AOV fell almost 10% and profit per visitor fell 8.42%, because the store was now paying to ship carts that were already buying. More orders, less money. The brand kept its original threshold.

The footwear brand shows the other side. At the smaller cut, the share of orders with free shipping rose from 11.9% to 18.6% and AOV went up, but conversion fell enough to pull profit per visitor down with it.

One practical warning: check what your testing tool calls profit. In some of our test reports, profit per visitor excluded shipping costs. In a threshold test, that leaves out the exact cost you are testing, so add what you pay per shipment before you call the result.

How do you know if your threshold is too high or too low?#

You can't know for sure without a test, but your orders tell you which direction to test first.

Signs your threshold may be too high:

  • Very few orders qualify. At the footwear brand, about 1 in 10 did.
  • Your best seller, alone or with your most common add-on, lands just under the threshold.
  • A shopper who came for one product has to add something they didn't come for.

Signs it may be too low:

  • Most orders already qualify, so the offer doesn't change what people buy.
  • Shipping takes a big share of the margin on each order.

Intelligems published a case that fits the second list. A sports equipment brand had a $100 threshold that more than 85% of orders already reached. It raised the threshold to $500, and revenue per visitor rose 12% and AOV 6%. That store was giving free shipping to almost everyone.

What we learned from each test#

Across our 27 free shipping tests, 7 won, about 1 in 4. Across all 1,379 tests in our A/B test win rate benchmark, 37.9% won. Free shipping is a hard lever to move, and the totals say little until you look at where each test started. These are the four changes we tested most:

ChangeTestsWon
Lowered the threshold64
Raised the threshold30
Removed free shipping20 (both inconclusive)
Added a progress bar, nothing else41
Outcome of 15 free shipping A/B tests by type: lowering the threshold 4 of 6 won, raising it 0 of 3 won, removing free shipping 0 of 2 won, a progress bar on its own 1 of 4 won.

Lowering it to match a basket won#

The footwear brand's deeper cut is the strongest result we have: conversion up 7.5% at 99.8% probability, on more than 360,000 visitors. Abandoned checkouts fell 5.1%. Profit per visitor rose 2.9%, though that part didn't reach 90%. Conversion won clearly and profit was moving the same way, not against it, so the brand kept the new threshold.

The household products brand's cut, sized for its core product plus one add-on, raised conversion 2.98% at our 90% threshold.

A sleep products brand lowered its threshold slightly, twice, nine months apart. Both tests were recorded as winners.

Lowering it too far lost#

The home decor brand tested two cuts at once, one below its AOV and one well below it. Neither won. The deeper one raised conversion but cut AOV by almost 10%. Lowering works when it removes a real obstacle. Past that point, you're paying for shipping you didn't need to give away.

Raising it lost in our tests, but that depends on where you start#

None of our three raises won. In all three, the original threshold turned out to be the better one. That's a result about those stores, not a rule about raising.

A luggage brand raised its threshold. Its threshold sat well below its AOV, so the bet was that a higher one would lift order value without costing sales. Revenue per visitor fell about 16%, and conversion fell too. AOV is an average, and an average can hide a lot of orders sitting between the old threshold and the new one. The test also ran in the weeks before Black Friday, which is not a normal period for any store.

A sleep products brand raised its threshold a little, right after lowering prices across its store. With lower prices, the higher threshold was harder to reach, and the result was negative on conversion, revenue and profit. A smaller raise a few months later was inconclusive.

The sports equipment case above shows the other side: when almost every order already qualifies, raising the threshold can pay.

Removing free shipping and raising the fee#

Happy Mammoth tested removing free shipping twice in 2024. Neither test moved conversion clearly, and in the first one, returning customers converted 8.66% more without it. But when Happy Mammoth raised its shipping fee by $1, conversion fell 6.19% and profit per visitor 6.06%.

How you show the threshold matters less than the number#

Progress bars won 1 of 4 tests when they were the only change. A supplements brand tested the same cart progress bar three times and never won; in one run, conversion fell 7.14%. On the other hand, a water purifier brand where every product already shipped free won just by saying so in the cart: conversion rose 4.89%.

How to test your own free shipping threshold#

  1. Look at your orders. What share qualifies for free shipping today, and what do your best seller and your most common basket cost?
  2. Pick a candidate that a natural basket reaches: one best-selling product, or a core product plus the add-on people already buy.
  3. Know what you pay per shipment, so your profit number includes it.
  4. Judge the test on profit per visitor. If conversion wins clearly but profit isn't conclusive yet, keep the change only if profit is moving the same way.
  5. Run it for at least 14 days and at least 10,000 visitors per variant. Our statistical significance calculator shows how long that takes at your traffic.
  6. Check whether discount codes change who qualifies. At the footwear brand, 36% of orders used a discount code, so it matters whether the threshold counts the order before or after the discount.
  7. Retest when your prices or shipping rates change. The footwear brand's earlier threshold data came from a lower flat shipping rate, and the sleep products brand's raise came right after a price cut.

Related Posts

Frequently Asked Questions#

What is a good free shipping threshold?#

There is no single good number. A good threshold is the one that earns the most profit per visitor for your store. In our tests, that was usually a threshold a common basket reaches on its own: one best-selling product, or a core product plus one add-on. Across 27 free shipping tests DTC Pages ran for 14 Shopify brands, the strongest win came from a cut that let a single product from the store's most common price tier qualify.

Should I raise my free shipping threshold to increase AOV?#

Only if your current threshold is too low, and only after testing it. In our tests, none of three raises won, and a luggage brand lost about 16% of revenue per visitor. But in an Intelligems case study, a sports equipment brand raised its threshold from $100 to $500 when more than 85% of orders already qualified, and revenue per visitor rose 12%. Check how many orders qualify today first.

Should I lower my free shipping threshold?#

Test it if your best seller or your most common basket lands just under the threshold. In our data, 4 of 6 threshold cuts won, and the clearest winners lined up with a basket shoppers already bought. Cutting far below what people spend did not help: one home decor brand gained 3% in conversion but lost 8.42% in profit per visitor.

How do I know if a free shipping threshold is profitable?#

Use profit per visitor: revenue minus product cost, discounts and the shipping you pay, divided by visitors. Conversion rate alone can mislead, because a lower threshold can bring more orders that each cost you more to ship. Check that your testing tool's profit metric includes shipping costs. In some of our test reports, it did not.

How long should a free shipping threshold test run?#

At least 14 days and about 10,000 visitors per variant, the minimum DTC Pages applies to every test. Two full weeks cover both weekday and weekend shoppers. Retest when your prices or shipping rates change, because the right threshold moves with them, and a result describes one period and one traffic mix.

Next Steps#

If you're not sure where your threshold sits, it's one of the first things we look at in a CRO audit: how many orders qualify, what your common baskets cost and what shipping costs you per order. You can see how we run tests like these on our A/B testing service page, or book a call and we'll go through your numbers together.

Want us to run this for your store?

We help 7- to 9-figure Shopify brands increase revenue through data-driven CRO. Book a free strategy call.

Book a Free Call

Ready to grow your Shopify store?

We help 7- to 9-figure ecommerce brands increase revenue through A/B testing, landing pages, and conversion rate optimization. No contracts, just results.